Content area
Full Text
On May 22, 1856, Preston Smith Brooks, a South Carolinian congressman, assaulted a seated Charles Sumner, antislavery senator from Massachusetts, in the Senate chamber. Brooks rained blows on Sumner's head and shoulders with his cane while Representative Laurence M. Keitt, a secessionist colleague from South Carolina, kept others at bay. Brooks later described the caning in a letter to his brother, "I struck him with my cane and gave him about 30 first rate stripes with a gutta perch cane. . . . Every lick went where I intended. For about the first five of six licks he offered to make fight but I plied him so rapidly that he did not touch me. Towards the last he bellowed like a calf." Stunned by the assault, Sumner was unable to slide out of his chair and was pinned under his desk, which was hinged to the floor. He finally managed to extricate himself by tearing the desk off the floor, only to fall down unconscious, covered with blood. Sumner suffered from several bruises and cuts; two serious wounds on the head exposed his skull and had to be stitched. In his frenzy, Brooks had received a minor cut in his head from the backlash of his cane. He continued to hit Sumner until a northern representative physically restrained him. The cane had shattered from the attack, and Brooks pocketed its gold head, declining the Senate page's offer to retrieve the fragments from the floor.1
According to the oft-repeated story, Brooks had become enraged on learning of Sumner's "The Crime Against Kansas" speech, which, he felt, had insulted South Carolina and his "relative," Senator Andrew Pickens Butler. He decided to "punish" Sumner and after lying in wait for him for a day, came upon him at his Senate desk. Brooks and his defenders claimed that Sumner incited the attack by using unusually offensive language.2 As some historians have argued, Sumner's famous speech and Brooks's subsequent assault and the reactions to the caning north and south of the Mason Dixon line revealed the fundamental political divide over racial slavery in the country.3 Instead of looking at the sectionalism the caning inspired or treating it as merely an incident of personal warfare, this article analyzes the discussion on...