Advanced Molecular Knowledge of Therapeutic Drugs and Natural Products Focusing on Inflammatory Cytokines in Asthma

Abstract

Asthma is a common respiratory disease worldwide. Cytokines play a crucial role in the immune system and the inflammatory response to asthma. Abnormal cytokine expression may lead to the development of asthma, which may contribute to pathologies of this disease. As cytokines exhibit pleiotropy and redundancy characteristics, we summarized them according to their biologic activity in asthma development. We classified cytokines in three stages as follows: Group 1 cytokines for the epithelial environment stage, Group 2 cytokines for the Th2 polarization stage, and Group 3 cytokines for the tissue damage stage. The recent cytokine-targeting therapy for clinical use (anti-cytokine antibody/anti-cytokine receptor antibody) and traditional medicinal herbs (pure compounds, single herb, or natural formula) have been discussed in this review. Studies of the Group 2 anti-cytokine/anti-cytokine receptor therapies are more prominent than the studies of the other two groups. Anti-cytokine antibodies/anti-cytokine receptor antibodies for clinical use can be applied for patients who did not respond to standard treatments. For traditional medicinal herbs, anti-asthmatic bioactive compounds derived from medicinal herbs can be divided into five classes: alkaloids, flavonoids, glycosides, polyphenols, and terpenoids. However, the exact pathways targeted by these natural compounds need to be clarified. Using relevant knowledge to develop more comprehensive strategies may provide appropriate treatment for patients with asthma in the future.

1. Introduction to Asthma

Asthma is a common respiratory disease worldwide. It clinically manifests as wheezing, nocturnal cough, shortness of breath, chest tightness, and variable expiratory airflow limitation [1]. An estimated 300 million people have asthma worldwide [2,3]. In the Unites States, the average annual prevalence of asthma is approximately 9.5% in children and approximately 7.7% in adults [4]. Asthma is the most common chronic disease among children. The prevalence of asthma in children showed marked geographic variation from 2% to 32% in different countries [5]. In 2008, an average of four missed school days for children and five missed work days for adults because of asthma were noted in the United States [6,7], which accounts for 10.5 million missed school days and 14.2 million missed workdays due to asthma attacks [6,7]. It is essential to control asthma, but poverty, inadequate health care, culture, and environmental pollutants are barriers to reducing the burden of asthma [5]. Significant progress has been made in understanding asthma. However, the cause of the disease is still unclear, and more information is needed regarding the complex interrelationship of the immunologic, genetic, environmental, and pharmacologic factors involved in the disease [8].

1.1. The Molecular and Cellular Basis for Asthma

Asthma is characterized by allergy, airway hyperreactivity, inflammation, remodeling of the airways of the bronchus, and the number of immune cells increased in the airway [9]. Many immune cells including dendritic cells (DCs), T cells, B cells, eosinophils, basophils, neutrophils, and mast cells infiltrate the submucosa of the bronchus and cause a series of immune reactions in asthma [9,10]. The presence of inflammatory cells in the airway results in an altered repair response, with the secretion of cytokines and growth factors that induce varying structural changes to the airways, which is termed as airway remodeling [11,12]. Airway remodeling includes elevated numbers of inflammatory cells, a hypertrophy of submucosal glands, goblet cell hyperplasia, hyperplasia of the airway smooth muscle, and the deposition of collagen and fibronectin in the subepithelial basement membrane or in the submucosa around or within airway smooth muscle bundles [9,11,13,14,15]. Abnormal extracellular matrix component depositions have crucial roles in the thickness of the airway smooth muscle [16]. The pathogenesis of asthma includes pathways of innate immunity, adaptive immunity, and memory immunity. Initially, the airway of a fetus does not contain DCs. After birth, microbes and irritants activate the respiratory epithelium. The main innate immunologic stimuli initiate the ingression of immature DCs from the bone marrow [17,18]. When airway tissues are damaged or undergo cellular stress or cell death, respiratory epithelial cells (ECs) express many pattern recognition receptors to rapidly detect and respond to pathogen-associated molecular patterns or damage-associated molecular patterns [19]. The overexpression of epithelial pattern recognition receptors leads to the secretion of cytokines, chemokines, and antimicrobial peptides [19]. Chemoattractants such as chemokine (C–C motif) ligand 19, 20, and 27 (CCL19, CCL20, and CCL-27, respectively) and the ligands for C–C chemokine receptor type 6, 7, and 10 (CCR6, CCR7, and CCR10, respectively) direct DCs migration toward the damaged epithelium and underlying mucosa [17,18]. In response to the damage, airway ECs release the cytokines of interleukin (IL)-6, IL-8, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), eotaxin, and tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) to activate and recruit more immune cells [20]. IL-6 is crucial for DCs to trap allergens and initiate Th2/Th17-mediated airway inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) in asthma [21]. Cytokines such as thymic stromal lymphopoietin (TSLP), IL-25, and IL-33 from damaged ECs stimulate myeloid DC maturation and activation [17]. TSLP, IL-25, and IL-33, which are all EC-derived cytokines and chemokines, play crucial roles in the initiation of innate immunity. In the human lung, IL-33 is predominantly expressed by bronchial ECs [10]. IL-33 is considered a damage-associated molecular pattern, and it has two major domains—an IL-1-like domain and an N-terminal nuclear domain—that activate the immune response after cellular injury [22]. After allergen exposure, IL-33 is rapidly released into the airway within one hour, which involves an increase in its concentration in the bronchoalveolar lavage fluid [22]. IL-33 may stimulate Group 2 innate lymphoid cells (ILC2) to increase the production of Th2-type cytokines, such as IL-13 and IL-5, in the innate allergic immune response [10]. IL-25 is a member of the IL-17 family and is similar to IL-33; it is expressed by airway ECs [23]. IL-25 is released when the cell is exposed to protease-containing antigens, such as house dust mite, and it is released by immune cells such as Th2 cells, mast cells, basophiles, and eosinophils [23,24]. TSLP is a four-helix bundle cytokine that can activate DCs, NKT cells, mast cells, and eosinophils to interact with cytokines and inflammatory mediators on the airway smooth muscle of patients with asthma [25]. In an asthma model, TSLP can upregulate natural killer T cells to increase IL-13 production and decrease airway hyperreactivity [26]. TSLP directly activates mast cells and induces mast cells to release multiple proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines independent of immunoglobulin E (IgE) [27]. TSLP can stimulate human eosinophils through the nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB)-dependent signaling pathway and the activation of extracellular signal-regulated protein kinase, namely p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase [26]. TSLP-like IL-33 and IL-25 can also stimulate ILC2 to increase the production of Th2-type cytokines [16]. In patients with asthma, re-exposure to allergens (such as dust mites, animal dander, dust, mold spores, and pollen) or environmental stimuli can cause an adaptive immune response [25]. Environmental antigens are immune-regulated, and are recognized by DCs, macrophages, B lymphocytes, and several other cell types that belonged to antigen presenting cells (APCs) [17]. APCs present antigens to CD4 positive (CD4+)Th2 cells through the endocytic pathway by processing eight to 10 amino acid epitopes in major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules. In allergic asthmatic patients, DCs play a crucial role in activating naive T cells. TSLP-activated DCs show stronger potential to express the OX40 ligand (OX40L; CD252) and can trigger the differentiation of naive CD4+ T cells into inflammatory CD4+ T helper type 2 (Th2) cells and the expansion of allergen-specific Th2 memory cells [28]. After this processing, Th2 cells-like mast cells and basophils produce IL-4, inducing B lymphocytes to switch antibody production and resulting in immunoglobulin class switching from IgM to IgE [29]. IgE binds to high-affinity and low-affinity receptors on mast cells, basophils, and eosinophils, causing calcium influx and degranulation. These cells release inflammatory mediators such as histamine, heparin, tryptase, prostaglandin, and leukotriene, which induce airway smooth muscle contraction, vasodilatation, mucus secretion, and increased vascular permeability. Th2 cells release various proallergic inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, and GM-CSF, which activate basophils and eosinophils and increase mucus secretion in the airway in patients with asthma [30]. IL-4 not only induces IgE production, but also stimulates the differentiation of naive T cells into Th2 cells and initiates the expression of vascular cell adhesion protein 1 (VCAM-1) to direct the migration of T cells, monocytes, basophils, and eosinophils to allergic inflammation sites [31]. IL-5 can stimulate eosinophil production and contribute to the differentiation, proliferation, and survival of eosinophils [32]. IL-13 has functions similar to those of IL-4, and can increase AHR [30]. Naive T cells can also differentiate into Th9 cells, Th17 cells, and regulatory T cells (Treg) cells. Th9 cells secrete IL-9 to stimulate mucus production, goblet cell hyperplasia, and mast cell development [33]. Th17 cells secrete IL-17A to stimulate eosinophils, and these cells influence airway smooth muscle [17]. Th17 cells overexpress IL-17A and IL-17F, which may aggravate the neutrophil inflammatory response [34]. Th1 cells secrete TNF-α and interferon –γ (IFN-γ) to activate neutrophils [17]. Treg cells can inhibit the functions of TH1, Th17, and Th9 cells, and can secrete IL-10 and transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β) to inhibit Th2 cells [17] After the series of immune reactions, some lymphocytes become memory T or B cells, which show immediate responses to the next allergen exposure. Sensitized ECs also release the fibroblast growth factor endothelin and TGF-β, which lead to the release of proteoglycans, glycoproteins, and collagen that cause airway remodeling [35]. A disintegrin and metalloproteinase-33 (ADAM-33), TGF-β, vascular endothelial growth factor, matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9), IL-5, IL-13, and IL-14 are key mediators involved in airway remodeling in asthma [35]. In a recent study, unregulated levels of connective tissue growth factor (CTGF) correlated with the MMP-9 level were found in the airway remodeling of asthma (Figure 1) [36].

Asthma is believed to be a chronic disease caused by the separate responses of innate and adaptive immunity to allergens; however, this concept has changed based on reports of ILC2 [37,38]. ILC2 are innate cells that can produce allergic cytokines without the need of adaptive T cell and B cell products [37,38]. TSLP activates DCs through TSLPR and promotes DCs to cause the differentiation of naive CD4+ T cells into TH2 cells to secrete Th2 cytokines, promoting the selective expansion of TH2 cells [39]. TSLP, IL-25, and IL-33 can directly stimulate ILC2 to secrete Th2 cytokines, and they induce antigen-specific IL-5 CD4+ T cells and promote allergen-induced inflammation independent of IL-4 [40]. TSLP may play a fundamental role in the innate–adaptive interface in the pathology of asthma [25].

1.2. Signaling Pathways Involved in Cytokine Activity during Asthma Development

Although many signaling pathways are involved in the development of asthma, we proposed three major signaling pathways for these three stages of asthma that we mentioned above. TSLP production by monocyte-derived DCs requires the integration of signals from dectin-1, the IL-1 receptor, and ER stress signaling pathways [41]. The NF-κB pathway is the first pathway that involves many epithelium-stage proinflammatory cytokines. NF-κB signaling is the first pathway in chronic inflammatory airway disease [42]. Also, the activation of DCs requires induction of the pro-inflammatory transcription factor NF-κB [43]. In both asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, oxidative stress contributes to airway inflammation by inducing inflammatory gene expression. NF-κB is an essential participant involved in many inflammatory networks involving chemokines (e.g., IL-8, macophage inflammatory protein 1 alpha (MIP-1α), monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP1), regulated on activation, normal T cell expressed and secreted (RANTES), and eotaxin), pro-inflammatory cytokines (e.g., IL-1, IL-2, IL-6, and TNF-α), adhesion molecules (e.g., intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM), VCAM), and E-selectin), and inducible pro-inflammatory enzymes (COX-2 and iNOS), which regulate cytokine activity in airway inflammation [44]. The T cell development during the second and third stages are endotype-dependent [45].

The second signaling pathway is the GATA3 and janus kinase/signal transducers and activators of transcription (JAK–STAT) pathways. Atopic asthma is associated with high levels of Th2 cells. GATA3 controls cellular function and predominantly promotes Th2 differentiation [46]. In the study of Shrine et al., the identification of the GATA3 and KIAA1109 signals are associated with moderate-to-severe disease [47]. Th2 cell activation occurs through JAK–STAT signaling. Targeting this pathway through the inhibition of cytokines (IL-4 and IL-13) and their receptors, JAKs or STATs, has been shown to have a therapeutic effect on asthma pathology [48]. The major JAK–STAT signaling pathway involved in the asthmatic response is the IL-4/IL-13/STAT6 pathway [49]. Several studies have explored the origins of Th17 cells in severe asthma. IL-1β and IL-6, each of which are critical to Th17 differentiation, are expressed at high levels in the inflamed airways of children with severe asthma [50]. Transcriptional factors such as RAR-related orphan receptor gamma (RORγt), STAT3, RAR-related orphan receptor alpha (RORα), and Interferon regulatory factor 4 (IRF-4), -are all involved in Th17 differentiation.

The final stage is correlated with Smad2/3-related signaling involving TGF-β. Also, the role of regulatory T cells (Tr) in this stage is also important.⁴⁵ TGF-β regulates multiple cellular processes such as EC growth suppression, alveolar ECs differentiation, fibroblast activation, and extracellular matrix organization that is closely associated with tissue remodeling in pulmonary fibrosis and emphysema [51]. The polymorphism of Smad3, which is involved in TGF-β signaling, is associated with asthma [52]. For the role of Tr, they can also inhibit ILC2s in mouse asthma models via the production of IL-10 and TGF-β. The suppression of human ILC2s involves the same cytokines [53].

1.3. Cytokines at Different Stages Play Crucial Roles in the Pathogenesis of Asthma

According to the disease manifestation, three allergic development stages can be described: (1) the epithelial environment stage, (2) the Th2 polarization stage, and (3) the tissue damage stage. For the epithelial environment stage of asthma (allergic sensitization stage), air exposure to allergens induces the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines (Group 1) in the airway epithelium, such as TSLP, IL-6, IL-8, TNF-α, IL-25, IL-33, and GM-CSF. In this stage, therapeutic strategies focus on the suppression of inflammation. TSLP is a Th2-prone cytokine that induces a Th2 environment. It activates DCs, and the TSLP-activated DCs develop a Th2-prone microenvironment. Lung DCs are a heterogeneous cell population that contains conventional DCs (cDCs), plasmacytoid DCs (pDCs), and monocyte-derived DCs (moDCs) [43]. DCs are professional antigen-presenting cells that shape T helper cell polarization through different surface molecules and cytokines including IL-12, TGF-β, IL-6, IL-23, and IL-1β [54]. Stage 2 of asthma focuses on T cell priming and allergen restimulation. After the airway environment is polarized to the Th2-promoting condition, DCs may induce the differentiation of naive T cells into Th2 cells, which eventually leads to IgE production by B cells. After restimulation with a different antigen, Th0 cells may differentiate into Th2 cells, Th9 cells, or Th17 cells, and secrete different cytokines (Group 2), such as IL-4, IL-5, IL-9, IL-13, or IL-17, to activate eosinophils, basophil mast cells, or goblet cells. Eosinophil and mast cell degranulation at this stage plays a crucial role in airway hypersensitivity. In Stage 3 of asthma, local inflammation is induced by Group 3 cytokines such as TGF-βand IL-10 in the bronchus and lung, which leads to tissue repair initiation. TGF-β contributes to tissue repair and fibrosis. In addition, TGF-β and IL-10 contribute to regulatory cell development (Figure 2).

2. Therapeutic Drugs for Asthma

Clinically, the main treatments for asthma are reliever and controller medications [1]. The strategies for the prevention and alleviation of asthma are complicated. Relievers are divided into three categories as follows: (1) short-acting inhaled β2 agonist bronchodilators (e.g., salbutamol and terbutaline), (2) short-acting inhaled anticholinergics, and (3) low-dose inhaled corticosteroids (ICSs) plus formoterol. Controllers are divided into four categories as follows: (1) ICSs, (2) ICSs and long-acting β2 agonist bronchodilators, (3) chromones, and (4) leukotriene modifiers. Add-on controllers are categorized into four categories as follows: (1) systemic steroids, (2) long-acting inhaled anticholinergies, (3) anti-IgE, and (4) anti-IL-5 [1]. Corticosteroids are currently the most efficacious drugs used to control and treat asthma [55]. They can reduce the number of eosinophils, T lymphocytes, mast cells, and DCs during respiratory inflammation; inhibit proinflammatory cytokine production; and decrease the incidence of asthma and exercise-induced asthma [56,57,58]. However, the long-term overuse of systemic steroids may have many side effects, such as the inhibition of height growth and an increase in the risk of osteoporosis, adrenal insufficiency, and diabetes [59,60,61,62]. Moreover, there are different endotypes of asthma, and some of these can be treated well with steroids, but there are still many cases with treatment refractory asthma; therefore, novel therapies are needed. Salmeterol is a long-acting β2 agonist drug that reduces the severity of asthma in children by suppressing TSLP secretion in human bronchial ECs [63]. The anti-IgE antibody marks the beginning of a new era of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) in the treatment of asthma. The humanized anti-IgE antibody omalizumab has been confirmed to improve the asthma symptom score, reduce the chances of acute asthma attacks, reduce the dosage of oral or inhaled glucocorticoid, and improve the quality of life of patients with asthma. Omalizumab also decreases airway wall thickening, decreases the percentage of sputum eosinophils, and increases forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) in asthma [64]. Omalizumab also reduces IgE-stimulated synthesis and the secretion of the proinflammatory cytokines IL-6, IL-8, TNF–α, and IL-4 by human airway smooth muscle cells (ASMCs) [65].

3. Clinical and Investigational Cytokine-Targeting Therapy for Asthma

Recently, cytokine-targeting biologics developed by clinicians have become potential therapy for asthma. In general, cytokine-targeting biologics for the treatment of asthma can be directly targeted through three mechanisms as follows: soluble receptors, anti-cytokine antibodies, and anti-cytokine receptor antibodies [66], and antisense approaches [67]. For three anti-asthmatic cytokine strategies, we summarized the different cytokines involved in each stage, and different stages target different cytokine candidates (Figure 2).

The potential cytokine-targeting therapies for asthma are discussed as below (Table 1). Group 1 consists of an anti-TSLP antibody, anti-IL-33R antibody, anti-IL-33R antibody, anti-IL-25 antibody, and anti-IL-6 antibody, which are investigational drugs for asthma. TSLP assists natural helper cells in inducing corticosteroid resistance in patients with asthma [68]. The anti-TSLP antibody decreases sputum and blood eosinophils and reduces allergen-induced bronchoconstriction in patients with allergic asthma [69]. The anti-TSLP antibody also exerts preventive effects on airway structural changes for smooth muscle thickness in asthma [70]. The human anti-TSLP antibody tezepelumab has decreased the annualized rate of asthma attacks in patients with uncontrolled asthma who were already being treated with medium to high doses of inhaled glucocorticoids and long-acting β-agonists [70,71]. The IL-33 trap is a new antagonist of IL-33 that has been proven to inhibit allergic airway inflammation in an in vitro animal study [72]. AMG 282 and ANB020 has been developed in clinical trials on asthma, and it is a drug that targets soluble IL-33 [71]. The receptors for IL-33 are expressed on many cells involved in the allergic response, including TH2 cells, ILC2 cells, macrophages, hematopoietic stem cells, eosinophils, basophils, mast cells, and fibroblasts. The anti-IL-33R antibody and CNTO 7160 have been studied in asthma, but the final report has remained unpublished [71]. Additionally, the anti-IL-25 antibody has been studied. The anti-IL-25 antibody significantly reduced the levels of IgE, IL-5, and IL-13; goblet cell hyperplasia; and eosinophil infiltration, and prevented AHR in murine asthma models [73]. However, no human clinical study of the anti-IL-25 antibody has been performed. The anti-IL-6 antibody for granulocytic airway inflammation therapies in asthma has also been reported [74]. A large number of human clinical trials of anti-IL-6 antibody have been performed. Group 2 consists of the anti-IL-4Rα antibody, anti-IL-5 antibody, anti-IL-13 antibody, anti-IL-9 antibody, and anti-IL-17 antibody, which are the investigational drugs for asthma. The anti-IL-4Rα antibody is directed against IL-4Rα and blocks the IL-4 and IL-13 pathways; this asthma treatment is under development [75]. The human anti-IL-4Rα antibody dupilumab increases the forced exhalation volume in one second, and decreases severe exacerbations in patients with uncontrolled persistent asthma [75]. Patients who received dupilumab had better lung function, asthma control, and significantly lower rates of severe asthma exacerbation [76]. Dupilumab is still under investigation for use as an add-on controller in asthma treatment. The anti-IL-5 antibody now is an add-on controller for patients with severe asthma. The humanized anti-IL-5 antibody mepolizumab improves FEV1 and reduces the number of eosinophils in the sputum and blood in asthma [77]. The humanized anti-IL-5α antibody benralizumab showed significant decreases in oral glucocorticoid use and exacerbation rates compared with placebo [66]. The Food and Drug Administration of the United States approved mepolizumab and reslizumab as new anti-IL-5 therapies for the treatment of severe eosinophilic asthma [78]. There has been a report on anti-interleukin-5 receptor α monoclonal antibody as an add-on treatment for patients with severe, uncontrolled, eosinophilic asthma. Benralizumab significantly reduced annual exacerbation rates and was generally well tolerated for patients with severe, uncontrolled asthma with 300 cells per μL or greater of blood eosinophils [79]. Although the study treatments were not connected with any deaths, serious adverse events occurred in some patients (<1%). The Food and Drug Administration of the United States also approved benralizumab as a new therapy for severe asthma. The human anti-IL-13 antibody tralokinumab decreased the use of β-agonists and improved lung function, but no improvement in the Asthma Control Questionnaire 6 score was observed in moderate to severe asthma cases [80]. The humanized anti-IL-13 antibody lebrikizumab improved lung function and the rate of asthma exacerbations in patients with moderate to severe asthma [81]. The anti-IL-9 antibody inhibited the pulmonary infiltration of inflammatory cells and decreased the production of cytokines IL-5, IL-9, and IL-17 in murine asthma models [82]. However, the humanized anti-IL-9 antibody MEDI-528 did not decrease asthma exacerbation rates and did not improve Asthma Control Questionnaire 6 scores or FEV1 values [83]. The anti-IL-17 antibody decreased oxidative stress, pulmonary inflammation, and edema in animal models of asthma [84]. The human anti-IL-17 antibody brodalumab improved Asthma Control Questionnaire scores, with nominal significance noted only for the high-reversibility subgroup asthma [85]. However, a study of anti-IL17A (brodalumab) in adults with moderate-to-severe asthma showed no improvement in asthma control [85]. There are still no Group 3clinical drugs for human: anti-TGF-β cytokine is the one recent anti-cytokine antibody in this group. In an asthmatic animal model, anti-TGF-βAb treatment prevented the progression of airway remodeling following allergen challenge, even when was given in a therapeutic model [86]. However, a previous study reported that anti-TGF-β treatment had no effect on airway remodeling and exacerbated the eosinophilic infiltrate, which led to increased airway hyperreactivity to the house dust mite-induced allergic disease [65]. Further evaluation is warranted. For the output of selected clinical trials on antisense drugs related to inflammatory disorders, cytokine antisense approaches on asthma are focusing on GATA3 [87] and beta subunit (β(c)) of the IL-3, IL-5, and GM-CSF receptors and the chemokine receptor CCR3; [88] their outcomes are safe and can reduce in allergen-induced early-phase and late-phase asthmatic responses.

4. Cytokine Immunomodulatory Effects of Natural Formula, Herbs, and Natural Compounds on Asthma

Many ancient countries have acquired knowledge regarding traditional herbal remedies. Natural formula, herbs, or compounds derived from plants have been found to alleviate asthma inflammation symptoms. Different groups of natural compounds according to their biosynthetic origin may be used as supplements for asthma prevention or therapy. According to the specific structures and bioeffects, anti-asthmatic bioactive compounds can be divided into five types: alkaloids, flavonoids, glycosides, polyphenols, and terpenoids [89]. Many studies have evaluated the immunomodulatory effect of these compounds by using the murine asthma model.

Herbal medicines and natural products are now used for integrative therapy and clinical drug development for asthma. In traditional Chinese medicine, treatment for asthma has been described earlier in Danxi’s Mastery of Medicine (1347 BC), but the formulas for asthma symptom relief, namely Xiao-Qing-Long-Tang, were described by Zhang Zhong-Jing in Shanghan Lun (219 BC). In this article, we summarize the regulation effects of herbal formulas on cytokines in the asthma model. Regarding formulas, Xiabai powder has been found to inhibit Group 1 cytokine (TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6) expression [90]. The antiasthma simplified herbal medicine intervention (ASHMI) alleviates asthma symptoms by modulating Group 1 cytokine (inhibition of TNF-α and IL-6) [91] and Group 2 cytokine (inhibition of IL-17, IL-13, IL-5, and IL-4, and enhancement of IFN-γ) expression [92,93]. The precursors of ASHMI, MSSM-002, inhibit Group 2 cytokines (the inhibition of IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, and GATA-2 and the enhancement of IFN-γ expression) to relieve asthma symptoms [93,94]. The modulators of Group 2 cytokine expression, such as the Sanao decoction, [95] Buzhong Yiqi decoction, [90] Shengfei Yuchuan decoction, [90] Wheeze-relief formula, [90] Wuwei Dilong decoction, [90] Bushen Yiqi decoction, [89] STA-1, [96] and modified Mai-Men-Dong-Tang [89] can be used in patients with asthma. Most formulas exert their beneficial effects by downregulating Group 2 cytokine expression, whereas only Xiabai powder was found to inhibit Group 1 cytokine expression [90]. Xiao-Qing-Long-Tang can regulate the expression of the cytokines in groups 1 to However, Xiao-Qing-Long-Tang exerts its effect only through the enhancement of CD4+ CD25 + Foxp3 + T cells and Foxp3; no data were found regarding its effect on Group 3 cytokine expression [97]. The cytokine inhibitory effects of herb extracts and major active compounds on asthma are presented in Table 2 [89,98,99,100,101,102,103,104,105,106,107,108,109,110,111,112,113,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136]. For example, the herbs Cordyceps sinensis, Thuja orientalis, Fritillaria thunbergii, Scutellaria baicalensis, Astragalus membranaceus, Curcuma longa, and Alstonia scholaris show inhibitory effects on Group 1 cytokines, namely IL-1β, IL-6, and TNF-α. However, the herbs and their active components are more effective at inhibiting Group 2 cytokine expression than the other two cytokine groups. Group 3 cytokines, namely TGF-β1 and IL-10, can be inhibited by Propolis, A. membranaceus (Astragaloside IV), Ligusticum wallichii, and Peucedanum praeruptorum ((±)-praeruptorin A). A. membranaceus and Astragaloside IV inhibit the Group 1, 2, and 3 cytokines, which may mean that the herbs show multifunctional effects on the expression of proinflammatory cytokines. However, the herb extracts have complex mechanisms of action (MOA) compared with conventional drugs. The MOA of herbs may involve pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion through various molecular signaling pathways. Additionally, the quality and consistency of herbs may be difficult to control, which may limit the use of herbal extracts as integrative therapy for asthma.

Natural products can be divided into many types according to their molecular structures and different bioactivities. In this article, we discuss five major types: flavonoids, triterpenoids and glycosides (saponins), alkaloids, polyphenols, and other compounds, namely triptolide; they exhibit unique activity for pro-inflammatory cytokine expression in patients with asthma. The effect and mechanism of these compounds are provided in detail in Table 3 [100,106,107,116,126]. The target pathways of these compounds are still unclear. However, some immunomodulatory mechanisms have been clarified. Flavonoids are powerful antioxidants that inhibit chemical mediators initiating Th2-type cytokine synthesis, and they also inhibit other mechanisms that involve mast cells and basophils. Flavonoids block IL-4-induced signal transduction and influence the differentiation of T cells through the aryl hydrocarbon receptor [137]. The target signaling pathway affected by polyphenols is the NF-κB signaling pathway [138]. Polyphenols suppress T helper 2 activation and promote the development of regulatory T cells (Tr) [139]. Flavonoids can also modulate DC functions either by dampening MHC-II and the costimulatory molecule expression or by inhibiting cytokine production, thus hampering the antigen presentation process [140]. Triterpenoids and their glycosides. (saponin) also affect the NF-κB signaling pathway, and they function as anti-inflammatory agents [141]. Alkaloids affect STAT6 and the forkhead box P3 (Foxp3), NF-κB, and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathways to modulate pro-inflammatory cytokine expression.

5. The Side Effect and Specific Outcomes in Asthma of Herbal Compounds

Most herbal formulas can alleviate AHR and late-phase inflammation for asthma. Especially, Sanao decoction and Xiao-Qing-Long-Tang can modulate the Gr 3 reaction. In the clinical trial, ASHMI, Ding Chuan Tang, STA-1, and Mai-Men-Dong-Tang have been evaluated; the outcomes are safe and improve lung function [186]. However, Ephedra sinica derivated from Shengfei Yuchuan decoction, Wuwei Dilong Decoction, and Xiao-Qing-Long-Tang have side effects on the cardiovascular system [90]. The bioeffect of a single herb for asthma treatment has been evaluated by the OVA animal model; otherwise, some study used an allergen-animal model to evaluate its bioeffect. Among them, Tripterygium polyglycosid and a major active component, triptolide, have side effects included hematologic abhormalities, gastriointestinal intolerance, infection, and infertility [84]. In the markets, natural products claimed multiple contents for multiple bioeffects, and the knowledge from biocompounds will apply to the new drug development field. We conclude that the natural component divided in Group 1 can provide preventive effects at the early stage of asthma development; the natural components divided into groups 2 and 3 have therapeutic potency. However, balance is key: too much of any of them has no benefit for prevention or treatment at all.

6. Conclusions

The pathophysiology of asthma disorders is complex. Cytokines play a crucial role in the immune system and inflammatory responses in asthma. Many inflammatory cytokines are involved in innate and adaptive immunity in asthma. Therefore, anti-cytokine antibodies/anti-cytokine receptor antibodies are potential therapy for patients who do not respond to standard treatments. Except for asthma, the efficacy and safety have been proven for cardiovascular, cancerous, respiratory, hematology, autoimmune and infectious diseases. As of March 2017, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved approximately 60 therapeutic MAbs until March 2017 that are currently under evaluation in various phases of clinical trials. Adverse reactions have been reported, including immune regulation disorder, other immune-related adverse reactions such as dermatologic, gastrointestinal, and endocrine, and reactions related to alterations in the immune balance, including undesired effects related to the target antigens and cytokine release syndrome [187]. No single cytokine is responsible for the entire pathogenesis of asthma. This is the challenging aspect of MAbs for asthma therapy. Therefore, the evaluation of anti-cytokine antibodies/anti-cytokine receptor antibodies for different phenotypes of asthma is essential.

In accordance with ancient pharmacopoeias, many medicinal plants show immunomodulatory potential and anti-asthmatic effects from the beginning of allergen sensitization to Th2 polarization, pulmonary inflammation, and fibrosis. An evidence-based study of natural medicinal herbs in treating asthma suggested that in addition to alleviating airway syndromes, many natural products have immunomodulatory effects, including modulating inflammatory cytokine expression and regulating the activity of inflammatory cells. Further research is warranted to explore the detailed immunomodulatory molecular mechanisms of these natural compounds to elucidate the in vitro and in vivo mechanisms of these active ingredients and ascertain their therapeutic management in asthma. Although these natural compounds, which have existed for a long period of time, can be used for preventive or therapeutic purposes, the precise dosage of natural medicinal compounds for patients with asthma still needs further evaluation. Traditional herbal products, especially formulas and single herbs, are widely used in asia. Although many studies have proved their biofunction, the standardized preparation, dosage use, and drugs interaction, and other side effects all need more effort to achieve safe delivery and efficacy [188].

Author Contributions

S.-C.L. provided the clinical therapeutic strategies and summarized the molecular knowledge and investigational therapy for asthma. L.-S.S. collected the different therapeutic activity of herbal medicine. Y.-L.Y. organized the writing structure and continue summarizing the relationship correlated with clinical drugs and traditional herbal medicine. All three authors prepared and complete writing together.

Funding

This research was funded by Ministry of Science and Technology, Taiwan, grant number MOST 107-2637-B-150-001.

Acknowledgments

We also thank Xuan-Shun Wang, Biotechnology Department of National Formosa University, for improving the art quality of Figure 1 and reorganizing the reference data.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Abbreviations

dendritic cells (DCs); epithelial cells (ECs); interleukin (IL); granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF); tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α); airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR); thymic stromal lymphopoietin (TSLP); innate lymphoid cells (ILC2); immunoglobulin E (IgE); nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB); antigen presenting cells (APCs); histocompatibility complex (MHC); T helper type 2 (Th2); vascular cell adhesion protein 1 (VCAM-1); regulatory T cells (Tr) ; interferon–γ (IFN-γ); transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β); a disintegrin and metalloproteinase-33 (ADAM-33); connective tissue growth factor (CTGF); matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9); major histocompatibility complex (MHC); macophage inflammatory protein 1 alpha (MIP-1α); monocyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP1); regulated on activation, normal T cell expressed and secreted (RANTES); intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM); janus kinase/signal transducers and activators of transcription (JAK–STAT); RAR-related orphan receptor gamma (RORγt); RAR-related orphan receptor alpha (RORα); interferon regulatory factor 4 (IRF-4); forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1); airway smooth muscle cells (ASMCs); forkhead box P3 (Foxp3); mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK); Food and Drug Administration (FDA) monoclonal antibodies (MAbs).

Figures and Tables

Figure 1. Cytokine profiles in the development of asthma.

Figure 2. Three stages for cytokine therapeutic strategies of asthma.

Table 1

Recent clinical and investigational anti-cytokine Ab for asthma therapy.

Group	Anti-Cytokine Ab	Drug
Group 1	Anti-TSLP Ab	Tezepelumab (Phase 3 clinical trial)
	Anti-IL-6 Ab	N/A
	Anti-IL-25 Ab	N/A
	Anti-IL-33 Ab	AMG 282 (Phase 1 clinical trial)ANB020 (Phase 2 clinical trial)
	Anti-IL-33R Ab	CNTO 7160 (Phase 1 clinical trial)
Group 2	Anti-IL-4Rα Ab	Dupilumab (Phase 3 clinical trial)
	Anti-IL-5 Ab	Mepolizumab (US FDA approved)Reslizumab (US FDA approved)
	Anti-IL-5Rα Ab	Benralizumab (US FDA approved)
	Anti-IL-9 Ab	MEDI-528 (Phase 2 clinical trial)
	Anti-IL-13Ab	Tralokinumab (Phase 3 clinical trial)Lebrikizumab (Phase 3 clinical trial)
	Anti-IL-17 Ab	Brodalumab (Phase 2 clinical trial)
Group 3	Anti-TGF-β Ab	N/A

FDA: Food and Drug Administration, IL: interleukin, N/A: not available, TSLP: thymic stromal lymphopoietin, US: United States. Transforming Growth Factor Beta: TGF-β.

Table 2

Relationship of cytokines with single herb and components. GM-CSF: granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor, IgE: immunoglobulin E, TNF-α: tumor necrosis factor-α.

Group	Components	Cytokines *	Ref.
Group 1
Cordyceps sinensis	CS-19-22 fraction	IL-1β, TNF- α, IL-6, IL-10 (–)(LPS-activated BALF cells)	[98]
Astragalus membranaceus	Astragaloside IV	IL-1β, TNF- α, GM-CSF (–) (Der p 1 activated human blood eosinophils)	[99]
Curcuma longa	Curcumin	IL-1β, TNF- α, IL-6, IL-2 (–)(DRA-challenged mice/ LPS-stimulated macrophages)	[100,101]
Thuja occidentalis	Extract	IL-6, TNF-α (–)(LPS-stimulated macrophages)	[102]
Fritillaria thunbergii	Extract	IL-6, TNF-α (–)(Human mast cell line-1 for childhood asthma)	[89]
Scutellaria baicalensis	Extract	TNF-α (–)(compound 48/80-induced HMC-1 cells)	[103]
Alstonia scholaris	Total alkaloid	TNF-α, (–)(LPS-induced airway inflammation in rats)	[104]
Group 2
Astragalus membranaceus	Extract	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–), IFN-γ (+)	[105,106]
	Astragaloside IV	IFN-γ (+), IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	[107,108]
Asparagus cochinchinensis	Saponin-enriched extract	IL-4, IL-13 (–)	[109]
Peucedanum praeruptorum	Coumarins	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–), IL-10, IFN-γ (+)	[110]
	(±)-praeruptorin A	IL-4, IL-5, IL-12, IL-13 (–)	[111,112]
Victis fructus	Pyranopyran-1, 8-dione	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)(Cockroach allergen-induced mice)	[113]
Glycyrrhiza uralensis	Isoliquiritigenin 7, 4’-DHF, liquiritigenin	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, GATA-3 (–), IFN-γ (+)(effector memory Th2 cells D10 and OVAsensitized/challenged mice)	[114]
Ilex chineses	Protocatechuic acid	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	[115]
Rheum officinale	Emodin	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	[116]
Lithonspermum erythrorthizon	Shikonin	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, TNF-α (–) (OVA/TSLP-induced BM-DCs maturation)	[117]
Ganoderma tsugae	Triterpenoid-rich extracts	IL-4, IL-5 (–)	[118]
Thuja orientalis	Extract	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)(LPS-stimulated macrophages)	[102]
Ligusticum wallichi	Ligustrazine	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, IL-17, TNF-α (–)	[119]
Armeniacae amarum	Water extract	IL-4 (–)	[120]
Morus alba	Kuwanon G	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	[121]
Pinellia ternate	Water extract	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, TNF-α (–)	[122,123]
Mentha haplocalyx	Ethanol extract	IL-5 (–)	[124]
Platycodon grandiflorum	Water extract	IL-4, IFN-γ, IL-5, IL-13, TNF-α (–)	[125]
	Saponins	IL-4, TNF-α (–)(IgE antibody-induced RBL-2H3 cell)	[126]
Scutellaria baicalensis	Skullcapflavone II	IL-4, TNF-β1 (–)	[127]
Echinodarus scaber	Hydroethanolic extract	IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	[128]
Propolis	Caffeic acid phen-ethyl ester	IL-4, IL-5, TNF-α (–)	[129]
Tripterygium polyglycosid	Extract	IL-5 (–)	[130]
	Triptolide	IL-5, IL-12, TGF-β1 (–)(LPS-stimulated MPM and human MDC)	[131,132]
Propolis		IL-10, IFN-γ, IL-5, IL-6 (–),	[133]
Cordyceps sinensis	CS-19-22 fraction	IFN-γ, IL-12 (+)(LPS-activated BALF cells)	[98]
Curcuma longa	FLLL31 (derivative of curcumin)	IL-17 (–)(DRA-challenged mice and LPS-stimulated macrophages	[101]
Anoectochilus formosanus	Extract	IL-4, TNF-α (–), IFN-γ, IL-12 (+)	[134]
Gynostemma pentaphyllum	Extract	IFN-γ (+)	[135]
Group 3
Astragalus membranaceus	Astragaloside IV	TGF-β1 (–), IL-10 (+)	[136]
Ligusticum wallichii	Ligustrazine	IL-10 (+)	[119]
Peucedanum praeruptorum	(±)-Praeruptorin A	TGF-β1 (–)	[111]
Tripterygium polyglycosid	Triptolide	TGF-β1 (–)	[132]

* The cytokine regulation in Table 2 are measured by OVA animal model, the special results measured by other cell or animal model were noted in the table. LPS: lipopolysachride; BALF: Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid; DRA: triple allergens (dust-mite, ragweed, and Aspergillus); OVA: Ovalbumin; MPM: malignant pleural mesothelioma and MDC: myeloid dendritic cells (mDC)).

Table 3

Relationship of cytokines with the compounds. NF-κB: nuclear factor-κB.

Type	Compound	Cytokine *	Mechanisms	Ref.
Flavonoids	Chrysin	Gr1: IL-1β, IL-6 (–)Gr2: IL-4, TNF-α (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway and caspase-1	[142]
	Kaempferol	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)(A23187-stimulated KU812 cells)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[143,144]
	Fisetin	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, TNF-α (–)(A23187-stimulated KU812 cells)Gr 1: IFN-γ, IL-8, IL-1β (–)	Inhibition of the MyD88 and NF-κB signaling pathways	[144,145,146]
	Quercetin	Gr1: IL-1β, IL-6 (–)(A23187-stimulated KU812 cells)Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, TNF-α, IFN-γ (–)Gr3: IL10 (+)(BV-2 LPS-stimulated microglia cells)	Inhibition of protein kinase C θ phosphorylationinhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[144,146,147,148]
	Skullcap-flavone II	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)Gr3: TGF-β1 (–)	Acting on TGF-β1/Smad signaling pathways	[127]
	Morin	Gr1: IL-1β, IL-6 (–)Gr2: TNF-α, IL-4, IL-13 (–)	up-regulated SUMF2 mRNA expression and down-regulated Leukotriene B4 receptor 2 (BLT2)/NF-kB mRNA expression	[149]
	Myricetin	Gr1: IL-6, IL-8, TNF-α (–)(Human umbilical cord blood-derived cultured mast cells)	Inhibition of protein kinase C θ phosphorylation	[147]
	Cyanidin	Gr1: IL-17A (–)	Inhibition of the IL-17A/IL-17RA interaction	[150]
	Tangeretin	Gr1: IL-6 (–)Gr2: IFN-γ (+), IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, IL-17A (–)	Modulate PI3K/Akt and Notch signaling and Th2/Th1 and Th17 cytokine levels	[151]
	Rutin	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, IL-17A (–), IFN-γ (+)Gr3:IL-10 (+)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[152]
	Kaempferol glycosides	Gr2: IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Inhibition of IL-4-induced transcription factor STAT6 activation	[143]
	Baicalin	Gr1: IL-6 (–)Gr2: IL-17A (–)Gr3: IL-10 (+)	Suppression of STAT3 expression and promoted FOXP3 expression	[153]
	Naringenin	Gr2: IL-4, IL-13 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[146,154]
	Esculento-side A	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Nrf-2 activation	[155]
	Genistein and Daidzein	Gr1: IL-1β, TNF-α (–)	Inhibition of STAT-1 and NF-κB pathways	[156]
	Pinitol	Gr2: IFN-γ (+), IL-4, IL-5 (–)	Blocking the transcription factor GATA binding protein 3 (GATA 3)	[157]
	Flavocoxid	Gr2: IL-13 (–)	-	[158]
	Apigenin	Gr1: IL-6, TNF-α (–)Gr2: IL-17A (–), IL-4 (–)	Blocking the transcription factor GATA 3	[146,159]
	Luteolin-7-O-glucoside	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Downregulation of T helper 2 cytokine transcript	[146,160]
Triterpenoid and glycosides	Astragaloside IV	Gr2: IL-4 (–), IFN-γ (+)Gr3: IL-10 (+)	Inhibition of the synthesis of GATA-3-encoding mRNA and protein in addition to increasing the synthesis of T-bet-encoding mRNA and protein in both lung tissues and CD4+ T cells	[107,108]
	α-Hederin	Gr2:IL-13, IL-17A (–), IL-2 (+)	Th1 cells (increases the Th1/Th2 ratio)	[161,162]
	Diosgenin	Gr1: TNF-α, IL1-β, IL-6 (–)	Enhancing the expression of glucocorticosteroid receptors, SLPI, GILZ, and MKP-1, and inhibiting the expression of HSP70	[163]
	Jujuboside B	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5 (–)	-	[164]
	Ganoderic acid C1	Gr1: TNF-α (–)(RAW264.7 cells and peripheral bloodmononuclear cells (peripheral blood mononuclear cells; PBMCs) from asthma patients)	Downregulation of NF-κB expression, and partial suppression of MAPK and AP-1 signaling pathways	[165]
	Lupeol	Gr1: TNF-α, IL-1β (–)Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	A mechanism distinct of glucocorticoids,	[166,167]
	Boswellic acid	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Decreasing the expression of pSTAT6 and GATA-3	[168]
	Celastrol	Gr1: TNF-α, IL-1β (–)(LPS-stimulated BV-2 cells)	Inhibition of extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1 and 2 (ERK1/2) phosphorylation and NF-κB activation	[169]
	B-Escin	Gr2: IL-5, IL-13 (–)	-	[170]
	Lupeol	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)(LPS-treated marcophages)	-	[167]
Alkaloids	Sinomenine	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)Gr3: TGF-β (–)	Inhibition of TH2 immune response, apoptosis of airway ECs and airway remodeling	[171]
	Chelidonine	Gr2:, IL-4, IL-13 (–)	STAT6 and Foxp3 pathways	[172]
	Protostemonine	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, IL-33 (–)(dust mites, ragweed and aspergillus-induced asthma)	Inhibition of STAT6, KLF4, and IRF4	[173]
	Ligustrazine	Gr2: IL-4 (–), IFN-γ (+)	Modulating key master switches GATA-3 and T-bet	[174]
	Ambroxol	Gr2: IL-4, L-13 (–)	Inhibiting IgE-dependent basophil mediator release and p38 MAPK activity	[175]
	Berberine	Gr1: IL-1β, IL-6 (–)Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13, IL-17 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[176]
Polyphenols	Epigallocatechin-3-gallate	Gr1: TNF-α (–)Gr2: IL-5 (–)(Toluene diisocyanate-induced asthma model)	Activation of the 5’ AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) signaling pathway	[177]
	Curcumin	Gr1: TNF-α, IL-1, IL-6 (–)Gr2: IL-2, IL-12 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[101]
	Ellagic acid	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[178,179]
	Resveratrol	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[180]
	Apocynin	Gr1: TNF-α (–)Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-12, IL-13 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[181]
Others	Triptolide	Gr2: IL-2 (+)Gr3: TGF-β1 (–)	TGF-β1/Smad pathway	[182]
	Andrographolide	Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)	Inhibition of the NF-κB signaling pathway	[183]
	Honokiol	Gr1: TNF-α, IL-6 (–)Gr2: IL-12, IFN-γ (+), IL-13, IL-17(–)Gr3: IL-10, TGF-β (+)	γ-Aminobutyric acid type A-dependent manner	[184]
	Thymoquin-one	Gr2: IL-4 (–), IFN-γ (+)	-	[185]
	Shikonin	Gr1: TNF-α (–)Gr2: IL-4, IL-5, IL-13 (–)(OVA + TSLP-induced BM-DC maturation, OVA-sensitized/challenged mice)	-	[117]

Gr1: Group 1; Gr2: Group 2; Gr3: Group 3; (+): upregulation; (−): suppression; −: no mentioned the detailed signal pathway. * The cytokine regulation in Table 3 are measured by OVA animal model, the special results measured by other cell or animal model were noted in the table.